Zoe struggles with lingering facial blindness and amnesia following a devastating automobile collision, finding comfort in her quiet romance with mild-mannered Blake. Her stability crumbles when she begins a new corporate job and discovers her demanding corporate manager, Ethan, is Blake's identical twin brother. Unable to visually separate the two siblings, Zoe constantly misinterprets small gestures and finds herself pulled toward the colder brother's magnetic presence.
Rather than clearing up her confusion, Ethan exploits their identical looks to slip into his brother's romantic shoes and insert himself into Zoe's life. But as haunting flashbulb memories of the past crash site begin surfacing, Zoe suspects her recollections have been manipulated from the start. She must uncover which brother pulled her from the wreckage before she surrenders her heart to an impostor.
